After-Hours
Menu
"When the lights dim, the real indulgence begins"
A late-night Prohibition-style menu featuring the best bites for the night owls, the wise guys, and the dames who like a little mischief with their midnight feast.
THE AFTER-HOURS SOUPS
The Starlet’s French Onion Soup
A rich, savory blend of seven onions in a flavorful beef broth, topped with a crispy crouton and melted imported provolone.
$10.25
THE SPEAKEASY STARTERS
Capone’s Shrimp Cocktail
Four large shrimp served with homemade cocktail sauce,
the way Big Al liked it.
$15.25
The Continental Shrimp Cargot
Succulent shrimp baked in rich garlic butter, topped with melted Havarti cheese, served with crusty French bread.
$16.25
The Velvet Glove Chicken Fingers
Crispy, freshly breaded, served with honey mustard—perfect for those who prefer finesse over force.
$13.25
The Flapper’s Mozzarella Sticks
Hand-breaded, golden-fried, served with warm marinara sauce—because some things should stay classic.
$12.25
Hitman’s Meatballs
Homemade meatballs swimming in marinara, topped with creamy ricotta—like Nonna used to make.
$11.25
The Outlaw Quesadilla
(Chicken or Veggie)
Grilled tortilla with melted cheese, caramelized onions, and your choice of chicken or seasonal vegetables.
$13.25
THE BOSSES' GREENS
Zelda’s Arugula Salad
Peppery arugula with Pecorino shavings and a light vinaigrette,
inspired by the legendary muse.
$13.25
The Sophisticated Caesar
Crisp romaine with creamy Caesar dressing, croutons, and Parmesan.
$13.25
The Underboss Chef’s Salad
A medley of fresh greens, meats, cheese, and veggies,
because a boss always eats well.
$15.25
*Add Chicken or Shrimp $7.25 | Add Tuna Salad or Chicken Salad $6.25
THE MIDNIGHT CLASSICS
The Starlet’s Fish & Chips
Beer-battered fish with steak fries,
tartar sauce, and lemon—crisp like a sharp suit.
$17.25
Diamond Garter Grilled Chicken Breast
Juicy, perfectly seasoned chicken breast served with your choice of side.
$18.25
Golden Age Fried Shrimp
Golden-fried shrimp served with a flavorful dipping sauce,
no under-the-table dealings required.
$18.25
Mobster Steak Tidbits
Bite-sized marinated sirloin steak pieces,
perfect for a sit-down or on-the-go getaway.
$19.25
THE CREW'S FAVORITES - BURGERS & SANDWICHES
Classic Cheeseburger
Juicy beef patty with cheese, lettuce, tomato, and pickles,
served with fries.
$14.25
The Untouchables Sliders
Three juicy mini cheeseburgers,
perfect for sharing or keeping to yourself.
$15.25
The Star’s Mahi Mahi Sandwich
Grilled or fried with lettuce,
tomato, and onion.
$16.25
Red Carpet French Dip
Slow-roasted prime rib on a hoagie roll,
served with au jus and fries.
$16.25
The Dreamboat Burger
Customize your perfect burger!
Base $15.25 + $3.25 per topping
Golden Age Chicken Sliders
Three crispy or grilled chicken sliders,
served with a side.
$15.25
The Enforcer’s Philly Cheesesteak
Sliced steak or chicken with sautéed onions, mushrooms,
and melted provolone.
$14.25
The Gatsby Pulled Pork Sliders
Tangy pulled pork with coleslaw on mini buns.
$14.25
Gatsby’s Gourmet Grilled Cheese
Indulge in one of our high-society grilled cheeses:
Classic Cheddar Mozzarella $12.25
Avocado & Bacon $14.25
Bacon & Cheddar $13.25
Tomato, Basil & Mozzarella $13.25
Smoked Mozzarella, Prosciutto, Tomato & Arugula $15.25
Buffalo Grilled Cheese w/ Chicken $15.25